- The Odyssey
2026 Cyclops
- High Tide
2024 Scott
- 4th Dementia
2024 Lou
- Rustin
2023 A. J. Muste
- Endgame
2023 Clov
- Spoiler Alert
2022 Bob
- Lust Life Love
2021 Richard
- Irresistible
2020 Elton Chambers
- Sesame Street's 50th Anniversary Celebration
2019 Mr. Noodle
- Confirmation
2016 Senator Jack Danforth
- Old Hats
2016 Writer
- Circus Kid
2016 Himself
- Sesame Street: Play All Day with Elmo!
2015 Mr. Noodle
- Ricki and the Flash
2015 Single Dad
- Show Boat
2015 Cap'n Andy Hawks
- Identity Theft
2015 Mark
- Interstellar
2014 TARS (voice)
- Never Stand Still
2012 Himself
- Sesame Street: Elmo's Magic Numbers
2012 Mr. Noodle
- Higher Ground
2011 Pastor Bud
- Sesame Street: 40 Years of Sunny Days
2010 Mr. Noodle (uncredited) (archive footage)
- Goldstar, Ohio
2010 Chief Jeff 'Goob' Garver
- Rachel Getting Married
2008 Paul Buchman
- Dark Matter
2008 Hal Silver
- Sesame Street: Elmo's World: What Makes You Happy?
2007 Mr. Noodle
- Raving
2007 Dito
- Across the Universe
2007 Uncle Teddy
- Lady in the Water
2006 Mr. Leeds
- Sesame Street: Elmo's World: Reach for the Sky!
2006 Mr Noodle
- Sesame Street: Elmo's World: Families, Mail & Bath Time!
2004 Mr. Noodle
- The Manchurian Candidate
2004 Scoutmaster
- Sesame Street: Elmo's World: The Street We Live On!
2004 Mr. Noodle (uncredited)
- Igby Goes Down
2002 Lt. Smith
- The Laramie Project
2002 Harry Woods
- Sesame Street: Elmo's World: Wake Up with Elmo!
2002 Mr. Noodle
- Elmo's World: Family Feature
2002 Mr. Noodle
- Sesame Street: Elmo's World: Happy Holidays!
2002 Mr. Noodle
- Sesame Street: Elmo's World: Wild Wild West!
2001 Mr. Noodle
- How the Grinch Stole Christmas
2000 Lou Lou Who
- Sesame Street: Elmo's World
2000 Mr. Noodle
- Sesame Street: Elmo's World: Flowers, Bananas & More!
2000 Mr. Noodle
- Sesame Street: Elmo's World: Singing, Drawing & More!
2000 Mr. Noodle
- A Midsummer Night's Dream
1999 Tom Snout
- Just the Ticket
1998 Ray Charles
- Illuminata
1998 Marco
- Waiting for Godot in San Quentin
1998 Himself
- Subway Stories
1997 Bill Irwin (segment "Subway Car from Hell")
- Silent Tongue
1994 Comic
- Sister Act 2: Back in the Habit
1993 Unnamed Brother #1
- The Last Mile
1992 The Maestro
- Memorial: Letters from American Soldiers
1991 Reader
- Hot Shots!
1991 Buzz Harley
- Stepping Out
1991 Geoffrey
- Scenes from a Mall
1991 Mime
- My Blue Heaven
1990 Kirby
- Eight Men Out
1988 Eddie Collins
- A New Life
1988 Eric
- Popeye
1980 Ham Gravy
- Mudflat
1980
