Brian d'Arcy James
- Finnegan's Foursome
2026 Teddy Finnegan
- The Family McMullen
2025 Walter
- The Copenhagen Test
2025 Peter Moira
- Hamilton
2025 Thanks
- Millers in Marriage
2024 Dennis
- Devil's Peak
2023 Bo
- She Came to Me
2023 Trey Ruffa
- Pain Hustlers
2023 Dr. Lydell
- Love & Death
2023 Dr. Fred Fason
- Dear Edward
2023 Bruce
- Let Me Go (The Right Way)
2022 Dr. Kemp
- The Cathedral
2022 Richard Damrosch
- How We Roll
2022 Executive Producer
- West Side Story
2021 Officer Krupke
- Hawkeye
2021 Derek Bishop
- Centaurworld
2021 The General (voice)
- Devs
2020 Anton
- The Comey Rule
2020 Mark Giuliano
- Bombshell
2019 Brian Wilson (uncredited)
- All These Small Moments
2019 Tom Sheffield
- The Kitchen
2019 Jimmy Brennan
- Dark Phoenix
2019 President of the United States
- Evil
2019 Victor LeConte
- Trouble
2018 Logan
- First Man
2018 Joseph A. Walker
- Song of Back and Neck
2018 Stone
- Rebel in the Rye
2017 Giroux
- Mark Felt: The Man Who Brought Down the White House
2017 Robert Kunkel
- Molly's Game
2017 Bad Brad
- 1922
2017 Sheriff Jones
- 13 Reasons Why
2017 Andrew Baker
- Manhunt
2017 Professor Henry Murray
- Time Out of Mind
2015 Mark
- Spotlight
2015 Matt Carroll
- Sisters
2015 Jerry
- Hoke
2014 Henry Hickey
- Mozart in the Jungle
2014 Ludwig van Beethoven
- Shrek the Musical
2013 Shrek
- Admission
2013 Christopher Flynn
- Ironside
2013 Bill Broughton
- The Fitzgerald Family Christmas
2012 Skippy
- Game Change
2012 Ted Frank
- Bird in a Box
2012 Walter
- Friends with Kids
2012 Husband in Restaurant
- Smash
2012 Frank Houston
- Person of Interest
2011 Wheeler
- The Big C
2010 Tim
- The Good Wife
2009 Detective Nolan
- Ghost Town
2008 Irish Eddie
- Rescue Me
2004 Dr. Felcher
- Monday Night Mayhem
2002 Al Michaels (uncredited)
- G
2002 Lloyd
- The Endurance
2000 Frank Wild (voice)
- Exiled
1999 Brinkley
- Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
1999 Adam Brubeck
