- Fast Charlie
2023 Stan Mullen
- Queen Bees
2021 Dan
- Out of Blue
2019 Col. Tom Rockwell
- Holy Lands
2019 Harry
- Con Man
2018 Agent Gamble
- Undercover Grandpa
2017 Grandpa
- The Red Maple Leaf
2017 Senator George Lawrence Secord
- Good Enough
2017 Roger Flynn
- The Good Neighbor
2016 Harold Grainey
- J.L. Family Ranch
2016 Tap
- The Outsider
2015 Schuuster
- The Throwaways
2015 Lt. Col. Christopher Holden
- Wuthering High
2015 Earnshaw
- Sicilian Vampire
2015 Professor Bernard Issaacs
- A Fighting Man
2014 Mike 'Brother' Albright
- Preggoland
2014 Walter
- Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs 2
2013 Tim Lockwood (voice)
- Blood Ties
2013 Leon
- Small Apartments
2012 Mr. Allspice
- That's My Boy
2012 Father McNally
- For the Love of Money
2012 Micky
- Detachment
2011 Mr. Charles Seaboldt
- Henry's Crime
2010 Max Saltzman
- Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs
2009 Tim Lockwood (voice)
- Mercy
2009 Gerry Ryan
- Middle Men
2009 Jerry Haggerty
- Get Smart
2008 The President
- Wisegal
2008 Salvatore Palmeri
- New York, I Love You
2008 Mr. Riccoli, the Pharmacist
- Santa's Slay
2005 Darren Mason
- The Incredible Mrs. Ritchie
2004 Mr. Harry Dewitt
- Dogville
2003 The Big Man
- Elf
2003 Walter
- Jericho Mansions
2003 Leonard Grey
- City of Ghosts
2002 Marvin
- Lathe of Heaven
2002 Dr. William Haber
- Blood Crime
2002 Sheriff Morgan McKenna
- Night at the Golden Eagle
2002 Prison Warden
- This Thing of Ours
2002 Jimmy
- In the Shadows
2001 Lance Huston
- A Glimpse of Hell
2001 Capt. Fred Moosally
- Dead Simple
2001 Roy Baker
- Warden of Red Rock
2001 John Flinders
- The Way of the Gun
2000 Joe Sarno
- Luckytown
2000 Charlie Doyles
- The Yards
2000 Frank Olchin
- Mickey Blue Eyes
1999 Frank Vitale
- This Is My Father
1999 Kieran Johnson
- Poodle Springs
1998 Philip Marlowe
- Bulletproof
1996 Frank Colton
- Eraser
1996 DeGuerin
- Bottle Rocket
1996 Mr. Abe Henry
- North Star
1996 Sean McLennon
- A Boy Called Hate
1996 Jim
- Flesh and Bone
1993 Roy Sweeney
- The Program
1993 Sam Winters
- Honeymoon in Vegas
1992 Tommy Korman
- The Godfather Trilogy: 1901-1980
1992 Sonny Corleone
- Earth and the American Dream
1992 Reader (voice)
- For the Boys
1991 Eddie Sparks
- The Dark Backward
1991 Dr. Scurvy
- Misery
1990 Paul Sheldon
- Dick Tracy
1990 Spaldoni
- Alien Nation
1988 Matthew Sykes
- Gardens of Stone
1987 Sgt. Clell Hazard
- Kiss Me Goodbye
1982 Jolly
- Thief
1981 Frank
- Bolero
1981 Jack Glenn / Jason Glenn
- Hide in Plain Sight
1980 Director
- Chapter Two
1979 George Schneider
- 1941
1979 Sailor in Fight (uncredited)
- Comes a Horseman
1978 Frank 'Buck' Athearn
- A Bridge Too Far
1977 SSgt. Eddie Dohun
- Another Man, Another Chance
1977 David Williams
- Silent Movie
1976 James Caan
- Harry and Walter Go to New York
1976 Harry Digby
- Rollerball
1975 Jonathan E.
- The Killer Elite
1975 Mike Locken
- Funny Lady
1975 Billy Rose
- Gone with the West
1975 Jud McGraw
- Rickles
1975
- The Godfather Part II
1974 Thanks
- Freebie and the Bean
1974 Freebie
- The Gambler
1974 Axel
- Cinderella Liberty
1973 John Baggs Jr.
- Slither
1973 Dick Kanipsia
- The Godfather
1972 Sonny Corleone
- Brian's Song
1971 Brian Piccolo
- T.R. Baskin
1971 Larry Moore
- Rabbit, Run
1970 Harry "Rabbit" Angstrom
- The Rain People
1969 Jimmy Kilgannon
- Submarine X-1
1968 Cmdr. Richard Bolton, RNVR
- Journey to Shiloh
1968 Buck Burnett
- Countdown
1967 Lee Stegler
- Games
1967 Paul Montgomery
- El Dorado
1966 Mississippi
- The Glory Guys
1965 Pvt. Anthony Dugan
- Red Line 7000
1965 Mike
- Lady in a Cage
1964 Randall Simpson O'Connell
- Irma la Douce
1963 Soldier with Radio (uncredited)
