James McCaffrey
- Murder at the Mansion
2020 Jimmy
- Mob Town
2019 Chief Lane
- A Good Woman Is Hard to Find
2019 Conor
- The Big Take
2018 Douglas Brown
- Destined
2017 Bill Holder
- Blind
2017 Howard Cunningham
- Romance at Reindeer Lodge
2017 William
- One Fall
2016 Werber Bond
- Oiled Up
2016 JC
- I Dream Too Much
2016 Nikki
- Coach of the Year
2016 Fred Call
- Confidence Game
2016
- Bait
2015 Male Stranger
- Sam
2015 Seymour
- Beyond Repair
2015 Producer
- Betrayed
2014 Sully
- Like Sunday, Like Rain
2014 Dale
- Gun Hill
2014 Alex Web
- A Cry from Within
2014 Father Thomas
- The Suspect
2013 Polaski Sheriff
- Stain Removal
2013 Jules
- Compliance
2012 Detective Neals
- To Redemption
2012 Nick Reed
- Excuse Me for Living
2012 Barry
- The Orphan Killer
2011 Detective Jones
- Montauk
2011 Roger
- Busted Walk
2011 Mr. Turner
- The Pregnancy Pact
2010 Michael Dougan
- NoNAMES
2010 Mr. Williams
- Camp Hell
2010 Dr. John
- Meskada
2010 Billy Burns
- Sordid Things
2009 Jagger Manchester
- Max Payne
2008 Jack Taliente (uncredited)
- Last Call
2008 Steven
- Feel The Noise
2007 Jeffrey Skylar
- Broken English
2007 Perry
- Hide and Seek
2005 Charlie
- She Hate Me
2004 Bob
- Fresh Cut Grass
2004 Sam
- American Splendor
2003 Fred
- Distress
2003 Jack Douglas
- Switched at Birth
1999 Darryl
- The Florentine
1999 Jack Ryan
- Coming Soon
1999 Dante
- The Tic Code
1998 Michael
- Nick and Jane
1997 Nick
- Hotel Shanghai
1997 Frank Taylor
- The Truth About Cats & Dogs
1996 Roy
- Burnzy's Last Call
1995 Sal
- Schemes
1994 Paul Stewart
- Viper
1994 Michael Payton / Joe Astor
- Telling Secrets
1993 James Merrick
- The Eyes of St. Anthony
1991 Tony O’Neil
- Bail Jumper
1990 National Guard
- New York's Finest
1988 Maitre d'
