- Margie Claus
2027 Santa (voice)
- Eugene the Marine
2025 Jackie
- Maintenance Required
2025 Mr Miller
- Jim Gaffigan: Live from Old Forester — The Bourbon Set
2025 Executive Producer
- Greedy People
2024 The Irishman
- Unfrosted
2024 Edsel Kellogg III
- Running on Empty
2024 Barry
- An Almost Christmas Story
2024 Papa Owl (voice)
- Jim Gaffigan: The Skinny
2024 Director
- Jim Gaffigan: Dark Pale
2023 Director
- Susie Searches
2023 Sheriff Loggins
- Linoleum
2023 Cameron / Kent
- Peter Pan & Wendy
2023 Sam "Smee" Smiegel
- Collide
2022 Executive Producer
- Reindeer in Here
2022 Santa Claus (voice)
- Hotel Transylvania: Transformania
2022 Van Helsing (voice)
- Jim Gaffigan: Comedy Monster
2021 Director
- Luca
2021 Lorenzo Paguro (voice)
- Target Number One
2020 Picker
- I've Got Issues
2020 Narrator
- Tesla
2020 George Westinghouse
- Jim Gaffigan: The Pale Tourist 2 - Spanish American
2020 Director
- Jim Gaffigan: The Pale Tourist 1 - Canadian American
2020 Director
- Drunk Parents
2019 Carl Mancini
- Them That Follow
2019 Zeke Slaughter
- Being Frank
2019 Frank
- Troop Zero
2019 Ramsey Flint
- The Day Shall Come
2019 Lemmy
- American Dreamer
2019 Cam
- Playmobil: The Movie
2019 Del (voice)
- Light from Light
2019 Richard
- Above the Shadows
2019 Paul Jederman
- Jim Gaffigan: Quality Time
2019 Writer
- Duck Duck Goose
2018 Peng (voice)
- Chappaquiddick
2018 Paul Markham
- Super Troopers 2
2018 Larry Johnson
- Jim Gaffigan: Noble Ape
2018 Writer
- Hotel Transylvania 3: Summer Vacation
2018 Van Helsing (voice)
- Chuck
2017 John Stoehr
- Jim Gaffigan: Cinco
2017 Writer
- Once Upon a Sesame Street Christmas
2016 Santa Claus
- Experimenter
2015 James McDonough
- Walter
2015 Corey
- Staten Island Summer
2015 Danny's Dad
- Hot Pursuit
2015 Red
- Jim Gaffigan: Obsessed
2014 Writer
- The Nobodies
2014 MC
- Kilimanjaro
2013 Bill
- Howard Cantour.com
2013 Howard Cantour
- Jim Gaffigan: Mr. Universe
2012 Writer
- Love Sick Love
2012 Andrew Blythe
- Salvation Boulevard
2011 Jerry Hobson
- It's Kind of a Funny Story
2010 George
- Going the Distance
2010 Phil Berlin
- Jim Gaffigan: King Baby
2009 Writer
- 17 Again
2009 Coach Murphy
- Away We Go
2009 Lowell
- The Slammin' Salmon
2009 Stanley Bellin
- Shoot First And Pray You Live
2008 Mart Ryde
- The Love Guru
2008 Trent Lueders
- Duane Incarnate
2008 Bob
- Stephanie Daley
2007 Joe Daley
- The Living Wake
2007 Lampert Binew
- Jim Gaffigan: Beyond the Pale
2006 Writer
- The Great New Wonderful
2005 Sandie
- Pale Force
2005 Writer
- Trust the Man
2005 Gordon
- Bad Apple
2004 Butters
- 13 Going on 30
2004 Chris Grandy
- Strip Search
2004 Reverend Craig Peterson
- Season of Youth
2003 Dr. Gelding
- No Sleep 'til Madison
2002 Owen
- Igby Goes Down
2002 Hilton Manager
- Super Troopers
2001 Larry Johnson
- Final
2001 Dayton
- Cry Baby Lane
2000 Bob
- Wirey Spindell
2000 Announcer #2
- Endsville
2000 Ivy Vaughn
- Hook'd Up
1999 Waiter
- Entropy
1999 Bucky
- Kimberly
1999 Jim at the Ad Agency
- Three Kings
1999 Cuts Troy's Cuff Soldier
- Puppet
1999 Mr. Kamen
- Not Afraid to Say...
1999 Larry
- The Real Howard Spitz
1998 Storekeeper
- Fool's Paradise
1997 Chester
- Crosshairs
Lyle
