- Wonderstruck
2017 Walter
- Dimension 404
2017 Bob (voice)
- Horace and Pete
2016 Tom
- Quarry
2016 Oldcastle
- Anomalisa
2015 Everyone Else (voice)
- 12 Monkeys
2015 Pallid Man
- Late Phases
2014 Father Roger Smith
- The Shape of Something Squashed
2014 Director
- The Leftovers
2014 Casper
- The Blacklist
2013 The Stewmaker
- Hell on Wheels
2011 Reverend Cole
- The Cape
2011 Preston Holloway
- Stoney
2010 Charles Stoney
- Bright Falls
2010 Hal (voice)
- Louie
2010 Dr. Haveford
- The House of the Devil
2009 Mr. Ulman
- Where the Wild Things Are
2009 Thanks
- Synecdoche, New York
2008 Sammy Barnathan
- The Alphabet Killer
2008 Ray Gullikson
- Seraphim Falls
2007 Minister Abraham
- Snow Angels
2007 Mr. Chervenick
- June Weddings
2007 RJ
- Damages
2007 Detective Victor Huntley
- Ice Cream Ants
2006 The Thinker
- Kidnapped
2006
- The Roost
2005 The Horror Host
- They're Made Out of Meat
2005 Duncan
- A Buck's Worth
2005
- Jonny Zero
2005 Chucky
- Hair High
2004 Principal (voice)
- The Jury
2004
- Madness and Genius
2003 Frank Donovan
- Eight Legged Freaks
2002 Joshua Taft (uncredited)
- The Pledge
2001 Gary Jackson
- Knockaround Guys
2001 Sheriff Decker
- Inside 'Manhunter'
2001 Himself
- Bullet in the Brain
2001 Anders
- Law & Order: Criminal Intent
2001 Malcolm Bryce
- An Unpredictable Thing
2001 Writer
- The Photographer
2000 Butler
- The Opportunists
2000 Mort Stein
- CSI: Crime Scene Investigation
2000 Zephyr
- The Beat
2000 Howard Schmidt
- The Astronaut's Wife
1999 Jackson McLaren
- Wang Dang
1999 Director
- Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
1999 Jake Berlin
- Phoenix
1998 Chicago
- The Wife
1996 Director
- Early Edition
1996 Frank Price
- Heat
1995 Kelso
- The Pesky Suitor
1995 Editor
- What Happened Was...
1994 Director
- Last Action Hero
1993 Ripper / Tommy Noonan
- The X-Files
1993 John Lee Roche
- The 10 Million Dollar Getaway
1991 Mr. Y
- Bone Daddy
1991 Director
- Red Wind
1991 Writer
- RoboCop 2
1990 Cain
- Collision Course
1989 Scully
- Mystery Train
1989 Man in Diner
- Monsters
1988 Director
- The Monster Squad
1987 Frankenstein
- Manhunter
1986 Francis Dollarhyde
- F/X
1986 Varrick
- The Man with One Red Shoe
1985 Reese
- Tom Goes to the Bar
1985 Tom
- North and South
1985 Will Fenway
- The Equalizer
1985 Brandon Thorton
- Best Defense
1984 Holtzman
- Tales from the Darkside
1984 Bill Lacey
- Easy Money
1983 Paddy
- Eddie Macon's Run
1983 Darryl Potts
- Wolfen
1981 Ferguson
- Heaven's Gate
1980 Jake
- Gloria
1980 2nd Man / Gangster
- Rage!
1980 Bo
- Willie & Phil
1980 Man In Park
- Roadside Picnic
Dr. Kirill
